2017-09-14 Indentation
Indentation is significant in Haskell. Haskell uses indentation to group pieces of code together. This is similar to Python, but there are “false cognates” - similar code that is indented differently in the two languages. In Racket, grouping is done only by parentheses.
Indenting to the same level
tip
“All grouped expressions must be exactly aligned.”Example 1a: good indentation
if x `mod` 3 == 0 &&
x `mod` 5 == 0 -- good. aligned with top x.
...
Example 1a: bad indentation
if x `mod` 3 == 0 &&
x `mod` 5 == 0 -- wrong. not aligned with top x
...
Indenting further
warning
“Code which is part of some expression [must] be indented further than the beginning of that expression.Not enough indentation
On one hand, this means that if you do not indent, you are not continuing a preceding expression. Example 2:
if x `mod` 3 == 0 &&
x `mod` 5 == 0
then -- wrong; needs to be indented further than the if
x
else -- wrong again
0
Too much indentation
On the other hand, if you do indent, you may be continuing something you wrote previously.
How could this be an issue? If you write one function and then indent a later function, Haskell thinks you want the second function to be inside the first function (as in, a “sub-function”).
Example:
main = do
putStrLn $ helper 5
-- all this space does not change anything... --
answer x = 200 * x
helper x = answer x + 1
Notice how answer is indented more than main? That makes the answer
function live inside of main… this will cause all sorts of
problems, but the first one is that helper cannot see answer
because helper cannot see anything inside of another function like
main.
The source for all quotes in this article is the Haskell article on indentation. Other example issues came from observations in class.